Cascadity Audio
← Political Spectrum
0

Supreme Court lets New Hampshire bar student IDs at the polls for the November election

The order is one paragraph plus Justice Jackson's short dissent; NBC explains what the 'safety valve' fight was about.

On October 22 the Supreme Court granted New Hampshire Secretary of State David Scanlan's emergency request and paused two October orders by U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante. A state law enacted in April removed student IDs from the forms of identification accepted when someone requests a ballot. Laplante left that law in place, but blocked Scanlan's guidance that student IDs could not be used for any purpose, including under a "safety valve" that lets officials weigh other evidence of identity. With the stay, NBC reports, student IDs cannot be used even as backup evidence in the Nov. 3 election.

The unsigned order cited precedent that lower courts "should ordinarily not alter the election rules on the eve of an election." Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented alone, writing that the injunction targeted misleading official guidance rather than changing the law. The Republican National Committee backed the state; the challenge was brought by the Coalition for Open Democracy. New Hampshire has an open U.S. Senate seat on the ballot.

From each bank
Across the spectrum 2

Democrat

Russ Muirhead, Democratic New Hampshire state representative (Grafton 12): Before the ruling, Muirhead said that when a voter has nothing else, the checklist supervisor can use other evidence of identity "and a student ID should do that," adding: "The fact of the matter is, students can use their student IDs to prove that they are who they say they are."

WCAX ↗

Republican

Republican National Committee: The RNC, which supported Scanlan, had warned that the lower court's order "threatens to disrupt identity verification in New Hampshire's looming elections."

Scripps News (CNN Wire) ↗
Rabbit Holes 1